[Day 3] Voting on a Pitch OLD
🥇 Your goal today is to create an environment where everyone gets useful feedback on their pitches.
Legend
🔸 Event host
🔹 Everyone else
🟢 Elected team facilitator
🥇 Goal: These will help you improvise.
This checklist is detailed, but you can reach the goals using your judgment if you think you can achieve them faster than the checklist suggests.
🟦🟦🟦 Headers, subheaders 1, 2, 3.
Headers are silent, don't share them.
🔄 Conditional
🟧🟧🟧 Basic Introduction
🔸 Say loudly: Welcome everyone! My name is ____, and I'll be your host.
🔸 Say loudly: Everyone who hears the sound of my voice, open the text channel related to this voice channel. The chat bubble in the top right or above this chat will open it.
🔸Say: For those who know how to "tag four people," you may do so right now to save time on the next step.
🔸Say: Today, we will be pitching and voting on pitches using a special negative vote method, which we'll explain later. The winner of today's pitch will get +6000 Helpfulness to help them win!
🔸Say: If you're new, in 1 hour and 10 min we will be doing a introduction for new people in one hour in the chat I will list in text chat now: https://discord.gg/89zuUNMFwj
🟧🟧🟧 Invites
🔸 Say: If you think this is the sort of environment that one of your friends would enjoy, feel free to send them a direct message or invite now.
🔸 Say: Making sure your teammates are here today is important because we'll be voting as a community on which idea goes through. You are free to leave one positive vote for your own team as long as you also vote for another team. Rally your people! Thing is, non-[P1] members can come in and vote!
🔸 Say: This might sound unfair, but you'll understand in a moment why we have a system where you can bring outsiders to vote. It's because we use a negative voting system, which will make sense once we explain it to you.
🟧🟧🟧 Voting
🔸Say: Now, we're going to listen to everyone's pitch, and I want everyone to write down positives and negatives of each pitch as you hear them on your own piece of paper. Then, when we actually vote, you will be sharing some of that feedback with the people who made the pitches in order to help each other succeed.
🔸Paste: Template for feedback for each game:
`# Game Name
## Going Well:
✅
✅
✅
## Improvements Needed:
❎
❎
❎`
🔸Say: Pitch quickly. You have 5 minutes, stay in the time limit or you will be disqualified.
🔸Say: As people pitch write down their game name and 3 points of positive and negative feedback at least.
🔸Say: Typically, when people pitch stuff, the advantage goes to the first person and the last person due to how human memory works. If you'd like to be the first team to pitch, speak up now. Speak up in voice chat only.
🔸Action: Time the pitches and make sure that they stay within 4 minutes. Disqualify them if they take more than 5.
🔸Paste this link: https://i.imgur.com/rs9LUi4.png
🔸Say: Now, in order from the first person to share their pitches to the last, I want you all to post in chat, with nobody else chatting, each different pitch with only 4 elements:
- Project name.
- Your one-sentence summary.
- Your planned impact on the world.
- A link to your team's registration. I have pasted a link which will show you how to get a link to your team's registration page.
That's it. Good luck everybody, prepare to do that right now. We're going to start with the first person that pitched.
🔸Action: Have everyone post.
Add a ✅, 🤚 and ❌ to every pitch.
🔸Open:
🔄🔄 If you have less than 13 pitches
🔸Action: Do this for each pitch:
- Remind everyone to write down their feedback for the pitch
- Give them 3 min to pitch
- Celebrate the pitch with the soundboard
- Highlight the pros of the pitch
- Bring up any cons
- Ask the community for feedback on the pitch 🔸Say: Anyone want to be brave and share some affirmations or concerns about the pitch? What are some things the pitch did well or where was it lacking?
- 🔸Say: Feedback is always welcome in chat too.
- 🔸Say: Anything that confused you about the pitch?
Do this for each pitch.
Feedback should be based on this criteria:
8 slide pitch
- Your idea put so simply that anyone can understand it in two slides -- use images
- How this game fulfills your goals
- How this game makes an impact on the world for good
- The art style in one slide (if relevant) -- color (choose 3 colors), style (low poly, pixel), other game examples.
- What the project will look like when complete and how long it will take the project to be completed if selected
- Who you are shooting impact (target audience)
- 50 words per slide is a MAX.
🔄🔄 If you have 13+
🔸Action: Do this for each pitch:
- Remind everyone to write down their feedback for the pitch
- Give them 3 min to pitch
- Celebrate the pitch with the soundboard
🔸Say: Now that everyone has posted their pitches, I want everyone to give two different pitches a negative vote. Two negative votes per person.
🔸Say: However, when you vote you MUST leave feedback along with your vote or it does not count.
🔸Say: Hover over the post and click reply as you leave feedback.
🔸Paste: https://i.imgur.com/pqpoj3i.png
🔸Say: New people can vote too!
🔸Say: Everyone should check the reactions to ensure no one cheats, but we're trusting people not to do so. Then, we need to post some feedback on why and how we think the pitch could be improved. This way, we're giving each other critical feedback, which is typically much more valuable than positive feedback.
🔸Say: But we must also grow a thick skin and not take it personally. We can use gentle language as we share how these pitches can be improved -- please include the positives. This way, everybody benefits from feedback from the whole community, unless their pitch is perfect. Include feedback on the quality of the idea, fun of the game etc.
🔸Say: 50% of the teams with the least negative votes win. The other 50% go back and try again tomorrow.
🔸Action: Hold the vote, choose the winners based on the least negative votes.
🔸Say: The 50% of pitches I just mentioned, those with more than the median amount of negative votes, are now approved ideas to go all the way to the finish line and build their prototype. The teams which did not pass today will have another chance tomorrow to try again.
🔸Action: The team with the least negative votes has won today's competition, giving them five bonus points toward final victory.
🔸Say: Team, you must remember to put this on your submission form; otherwise, those bonus points won't count. Let them know via the submission form when you get it that you won this competition.
🔸Say: Congratulations!
🔸Say: Those teams that did not make it to the top 50% today can still continue forward with their ideas using the feedback given today OR they can join the winning teams. The winning parties get started with their game and the rest prep the repitch for tomorrow.
🔸Say: If you would like to join one of the teams that presented today, hit the ✋on the team you want to join. Then reply to their post with your skill set.
DONE IGNORE REST
🟧🟧🟧 Teams Vote On Weekend Meeting Times
🔸Say: Now, let's find a time this weekend for each team to meet and go over important mentorship material to help their games and projects succeed.
🔸Say: Split teams and have them find a time to do this.
🔸Say: Have them set a 10 min timer and come back.
🟧🟧🟧 Onboarding
🔸Say: If you are brand new here, now is your time to speak up.
🔸Say: All new members say your name in chat and post 1 sentence about your skill set. 3, 2, 1, go!
🔸Wait & look for new faces and call them out "are you new here". Ask Samuel to add a special role to new people if he has not already (DM).
🔸Get link and paste in chat: This checklist link. Use it to onboard new people -- there is a reward for those who do.
🔸Say: You know how we talked about stepping up and seizing opportunities? This is your chance to push your boundaries and gain experiences. Opportunity doesn't always knock, so seize it while it does. Go ahead and bring these people onto your teams. Again the meeting ends right after this so you won't miss anything. We can't end until each new person has a team to go to!
🔸Say: Don't go on without properly onboarding all your new members using the checklist I posted in chat. Say "I" when you see the checklist!
🔸 Wait for 50% to say I.
🔸 Have each team choose a voice channel, starting with the one that scored the highest.
🔸Say: Now you and the new people who joined your team must take the following checklist and go to your channel now.
🔸Say: Now it's time for the teams left that haven't onboarded somebody to continue working on your pitches or, in case of winners, working on your games. If you want to know how to work on your pitches, just go through this checklist. I'll go ahead and post it in chat for you.
🔸Say: Ok teams, break up to your team channels!
🔸Action: Make sure everyone knows what to do and where to go.


